This is kind of a weird one.
I was mulling over the question of what happens when the market opens up, i.e. above its previous close. Is the day likely to be an up day? A down day? I got out of my data and started poking around. I looked at all “open-up” days with an open at least 0.25% above the previous day’s close. I looked at only days that opened up after a previous close-to-close down day. And the reverse.
The statistics were not significant, although it appeared there was something of a shorting opportunity there. I therefore put together a backtest for shorting at the open and holding to the close, and that looked like utter garbage.
So I flipped it. Hmm, getting something interesting here. I made a few tweaks (making sure to only look at my in-sample data while doing so). I came up with an impractical* system that looks good in the out-of-sample testing as well.
Here’s the system:
I find it interesting that this system does OK during bull markets, and does even better – on the long side! – during bear markets.
*Why is this system impractical? It only traded 262 times. That’s only 6% of the total trading days where an order actually placed. That’s what I call a fussy little system. You would not be placing a buy-stop-on-open** order every day… only on the days where your ATR signal appeared. I don’t know how many days that would be, because I can’t be bothered to count them.
OK fine, I’ll count them. 2,055 days. Roughly half of all trading days. Ten percent-ish of the time, you get a trade. I’d want that automated, thank you very much.
**Not to mention, “buy-stop on open” isn’t a real order type (that I know of). You’d have to have your buy-stop in place, and then cancel it immediately after the open. Or you’d have your robot monitor the price just as the market opens, and put a quick buy in. There would be slippage and missed buys and possibly buys when you really didn’t want to.
I present this to you because it might generate ideas of your own. The system is checking for an increase in ATR, which means volatility is increasing. Does that mean “open-up days” tend to have momentum when volatility is higher? Is this a result of slightly longer term mean-reversion during periods of higher volatility? Get your slipsticks out and figure it out for yourself!
–by Matt Haines from Throwing Good Money
Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.