This Simple Indicator Makes Money Again and Again

Here we are four months into 2016 and I’ve not updated some of the more interesting articles. One of those is Connors’ 2-period RSI strategy. This is a very popular trading method by Larry Connors and Cesar Alvarez. We all know there are no magic indicators but there is an indicator that certainly acted like magic over several decades. What indicator is it? Our reliable RSI indicator.

Over the past few years the standard 2-period trading model as defined in the book, “Short Term Trading Strategies That Work”, has been in a drawdown. During 2011 the market experienced a sudden and sustained drop which put the trading model into loss. Recall, the trading model had no stops. Since this drop the model has been slowly recovering. Below is an equity graph depicting the trading model’s equity curve trading the SPX index from 1980. You can easily see the large drop around trade number 135.

RSI2_2015

RSI2_Results_2015

Here is a closeup view of the last 30 trades, which covers about the last seven years. We can see this system is making new equity highs in 2015.

RSI2_Recent_2015

The trading model as originally proposed by Larry Connors is very simple and consist of long-only trades. As a reminder, the rules are as follows:

  • Price must be above its 200-day moving average.
  • Buy on close when cumulative RSI(2) is below 5.
  • Exit when price closes above the 5-day moving average.

All the tests within this article are going to use the following assumptions:

  • Starting Equity: $100,000.
  • Number of shares is normalized based on a 10-day ATR calculation with a $2,000 risk per trade.
  • There are no stops.
  • The P&L of each trade is not reinvested.
  • Commissions & Slippage are not accounted for.

Below is the annual performance of this trading model over the past few years.

RSI2_Returns_2015

Modified Trading Model

Back in the year 2013, I explored the robustness of the trading parameters used by the 2-period RSI trading model. That article can be found here. Within that article a slightly modified version of the original trading rules was proposed. In short, they doubled the value of the RSI threshold value (from 5 to 10) and doubled the look-back period for the simple moving average exit rule (from 5 to 10). Finally, a stop value of $2,000 was added. I picked this value because it represents our risk value when scaling the number of shares to trade. Notice we are only risking 2% of our $100,000 account on each trade. Here is a summary of the rule changes.

  • Use a value of 10 as the RSI threshold.
  • Use a 10-period simple moving average as our exit signal.
  • Use a $2,000 hard stop.

Below is a table showing the difference between the original Connors’ rules and the modified Connors’ rules.

RS2_Mod_2015

RSI2_Connors_vs_mod_2015

Our increase in net profit comes at the cost of more trades which is due to the fact of lowering the stand on what we consider a viable pullback. By increasing the RSI threshold from 5 to 10 more setups qualify as a valid entry, we take more trades. But we also increased our look-back period for our exit calculation. Thus, we should be holding some of the trades a little longer in an attempt to make more profit. The stop value does hurt the performance of our model. For example, removing the stop value will result in $178,000 in profit with a profit factor of 2.92. However, we’re going to keep the stop in place because trading without a stop is something most people will not be doing! It will also help protect us from massive losing trades as seen in 2011.

Other Markets

I tested the 2-period systems on the $SPX.X index which is not a tradable instrument. I did this to get as much backtest history as possible. But how would my modified 2-period RSI system hold up on real ETF and futures markets?

RSI2_Other_Markets_2015

Conclusion

The RSI indicator still appears to be a robust indicator at locating high probability entry points within the major market indices. You can modify the trigger threshold and holding period over a large range of values and still produce positive trading results. I hope this article will give you lots of ideas to explore on your own. Another idea with regards to testing parameters is to independently optimize the parameters over the “portfolio” of market ETFs instead of using just $SPX.  There is no doubt in my mind the RSI indicator can be used as a basis for a profitable trading system.

Get The Book

Short Term Trading Strategies That Work

Downloads

RSI2 Strategy Files (TradeStation ELD)
RSI2 WorkSpace (TradeStation TSW)
RSI2 Strategy File (Text file)

About the Author Jeff Swanson

Jeff is the founder of System Trader Success - a website and mission to empowering the retail trader with the proper knowledge and tools to become a profitable trader the world of quantitative/automated trading.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment:

45 comments
Add Your Reply